Monte Climb

How to Improve Your Monte Carlo Retirement Success Rate: 8 Levers

A low Monte Carlo score isn't a verdict. Here are eight levers that can raise your Monte Carlo retirement success rate, starting with the two that usually matter most: checking your inputs and building some flexibility into your spending.

You ran the numbers and the screen says 72%. Now what? Start here: 3.9%. Morningstar's research, published December 2025, puts the safe starting withdrawal rate for 2026 at 3.9%, up from 3.7% a year earlier. "Safe" means the money is still there in 90% of simulated 30-year retirements (Morningstar, The State of Retirement Income 2026). That's a probability, the same kind of number your score is. If you want to know how to improve your Monte Carlo retirement success rate, the short answer is this. Check your inputs first. Then build some flexibility into your spending. Working longer, timing Social Security and adjusting your portfolio come after that.

Here's what each lever does and when it can backfire.

First, what the score actually means

A Monte Carlo simulation runs your plan through many possible futures. Each one has its own random mix of good years, bad years and inflation. Your success rate is the share of those futures where the money lasts. If 720 out of 1,000 stay funded, you get 72%.

Two things to know before you change anything:

  • The score doesn't tell you how badly a plan fails. A future that runs dry at 94 counts the same as one that runs dry at 75.
  • A "failure" usually means you'd have to adjust, not that you'd be broke. Kitces suggests calling it a "probability of adjustment" instead (Kitces). In the real world you'd cut back long before you hit zero.

What success rate should you aim for?

Not 100%. David Blanchett argues that around 80% is a reasonable target for most people. He also notes that a plan with only a 50% success rate can still have its average run reach 96% of the spending goal (Advisor Perspectives, "The Problems with Monte Carlo Are in Your Mind," April 2023). T. Rowe Price makes a similar point. A very high score can mean you're underspending, or working longer than you need to (T. Rowe Price, 2025).

So the goal is a score you can live with, plus a plan for what you'll do if things go badly.

How to improve your Monte Carlo retirement success rate: 8 levers

1. Fix your inputs before you fix your plan

Bad inputs give you bad results. Before you cut spending or move your retirement date, make sure the simulation is answering the right question.

  • Is your monthly spending real or a guess? EBRI's 2025 Retirement Confidence Survey found only 52% of workers have estimated the monthly income they'll need in retirement (EBRI/Greenwald, Fact Sheet 3). If you're guessing, your score is a guess too.
  • How long does the plan run? About one in three 65-year-olds may live to at least 90, according to the Social Security Administration. If your plan stops at 85, it's betting against a third of retirees. The plan you build with us runs to 95 by default, and you can push it further.
  • Is health care in there? Fidelity's 2025 estimate is $172,500 in Medicare premiums, deductibles and prescriptions for one 65-year-old over retirement. That figure doesn't include long-term care. Our engine charges Medicare premiums and income-based surcharges year by year instead of using a flat guess.

Fixing your inputs can lower your score. That's fine. An honest 75% is worth more than a flattering 90%.

2. Model spending that falls over time

Many simulations keep your spending flat after inflation for 30 years. Real retirees usually don't spend that way. Blanchett's research found real spending tends to fall about 1% a year during retirement (White Coat Investor). Morningstar used a 2% yearly decline in some of its own modeling (Morningstar, "The Best Flexible Strategies for Retirement Income").

If you expect your spending to taper off and your model doesn't, your score is probably too low. Just be honest about it. Higher health care costs later in life can cancel out some of that decline.

3. Trim your starting spending

This is the simplest lever. Every dollar you don't take out in the early years keeps growing, and early bad years do the most damage to a portfolio. A small, lasting cut to your starting withdrawal often helps more than a big cut later.

Compare your withdrawal rate with the 3.9% benchmark. To get it, take your yearly portfolio withdrawals and divide by your savings. Morningstar's figure doesn't count Social Security, so subtract any guaranteed income from your spending first. If you're well above 3.9%, your score will show it.

4. Add guardrails (flexible spending)

This is often the most powerful lever. Guardrails are pre-agreed rules. You spend less after bad markets and allow yourself more after good ones.

  • Morningstar's 2026 research found flexible withdrawal methods can support starting rates as high as 5.7%, compared with 3.9% for a fixed approach (Morningstar).
  • One sample rule: if your inflation-adjusted withdrawal rate climbs 20% above where it started, cut spending by 10%. Morningstar found guardrail approaches more efficient than the classic 4% rule (Morningstar).
  • In one Newfound Research simulation, cutting withdrawals when the portfolio fell below a threshold raised the success rate to 99%. It also made the income cuts much smaller (Newfound Research, 2019).

The trade-off is that your income moves around. Guardrails only work if you'll really cut back when the rule says so. Decide now which spending is essential and which is optional.

5. Work a little longer

An extra year of work helps in three ways. You add a year of savings. You take out one less year of withdrawals. And you shorten the stretch your portfolio has to cover. Even a part-time year or a phased exit can help.

This lever is often in your control, but not always. Health, layoffs and caregiving can make the decision for you. Treat a later date as one option to test, not the whole plan.

6. Consider delaying Social Security, carefully

Waiting to claim gets you a larger, inflation-adjusted benefit for life. That helps most in long-life scenarios, which are exactly the futures where plans tend to fail.

But this lever can backfire. AAII's analysis found that for people with little saved, delaying Social Security can lower the odds of success. You draw down a small portfolio hard while you wait, and a bad market in those years hurts (AAII). Run both claiming ages and compare. Don't assume.

7. Revisit your asset allocation

Your mix of stocks and bonds affects both how much your portfolio can grow and how badly it can fall. If you hold very little in stocks, you may not keep up with a long retirement and inflation. If you hold a lot, a bad first few years can hurt you badly.

There's no universal right answer. Your best mix depends on your spending, other income and how much ups and downs you can handle. Test a couple of options and see how the score and the bad outcomes change. Don't chase the single highest number.

8. Add guaranteed income

Guaranteed income, such as a pension, a later Social Security claim or an annuity, covers part of your spending no matter what markets do. The portfolio then has less to carry. Annuities are a common fix for plans that fall short, though they come with costs and trade-offs worth understanding before you buy one.

Which levers backfire, and for whom

Lever Usually helps when… Can backfire when…
Fix inputs Always It can lower your score. That's the point.
Model falling spending Your spending really is likely to taper You underestimate later health or care costs
Trim starting spending Your withdrawal rate is well above 3.9% You're already spending at a modest level
Guardrails You have optional spending you can cut You won't actually stick to the cuts
Work longer Your health and job allow it It's assumed, not chosen
Delay Social Security You have enough savings to cover the gap Your savings are small (per AAII)
Change allocation Your current mix is extreme either way You're chasing the highest score
Guaranteed income Your essential costs aren't covered Fees or lost flexibility outweigh the benefit

Look past the score

Once you've pulled a few levers, don't just look at whether the number went up. Ask:

  • How bad do the failures get? Running short in your mid-90s is very different from running short in your 70s.
  • What would I actually do in a bad decade? If you have an answer, a "failed" future becomes an adjustment.
  • Did I change one thing at a time? Change one lever, rerun, and write down the result. That's how you find out which levers matter for your numbers. The research can't tell you that.

Run your own numbers

Every lever above works differently for different households. The only way to know which ones matter for you is to test them on your own numbers. You need three: your age, what you've saved and what you spend each month. We run them through 1,000 simulated futures and give you a success rate. Then you can ask William, our AI planner, follow-ups like "Am I on track?" or "Can I retire at 62?" He shows his work. Everything runs in your browser, and nothing is saved until you say so.

It's planning software, not advice. And your result is a probability, not a promise.

Show my answer →

Frequently asked questions

What is a good Monte Carlo retirement success rate?

For most people, around 80% is a reasonable target, according to David Blanchett (Advisor Perspectives, 2023). Aiming for 100% can mean you're underspending or working longer than you need to. A 'failed' future usually means you'd need to adjust your spending, not that you'd run out of money overnight.

What is the fastest way to raise my Monte Carlo success rate?

First check your inputs: accurate monthly spending, a long enough planning horizon and realistic health care costs. After that, flexible spending (guardrails) is often the strongest lever. Morningstar's 2026 research found flexible methods can support starting withdrawal rates as high as 5.7%, compared with 3.9% for fixed spending.

Does delaying Social Security always improve my success rate?

No. A later claim gets you a bigger lifetime benefit, which helps in long-life scenarios. But AAII found that for people with little saved, delaying can lower success odds because the portfolio gets drawn down hard while you wait. Test both claiming ages on your own numbers.

What is the safe withdrawal rate for 2026?

Morningstar puts the safe starting withdrawal rate for 2026 at 3.9%, up from 3.7% for 2025. 'Safe' means money remains in 90% of simulated 30-year retirements, and the figure doesn't include Social Security.

Why might my Monte Carlo score be too low?

Many models hold spending flat after inflation for the whole retirement. Blanchett's research found real spending tends to fall about 1% a year, so a flat-spending model can understate your odds. Other assumptions matter too, such as how long the plan runs and how health care costs are handled.

When can you actually retire?

Three numbers. We run your savings through 1,000 simulated futures, the same engine behind the app, and give you one clear answer.

Show my answer

Get new posts by email

We'll email you new Monte Climb posts once the newsletter starts. Nothing has been sent yet.

We keep only your email address and the post you signed up from, and delete it whenever you ask. Privacy policy

Keep reading