The Disadvantages of Retiring at 62, Stress-Tested

About 30%. If your full retirement age is 67, which applies to everyone born in 1960 or later, that's roughly how much smaller your Social Security check gets if you claim at 62. The cut is permanent. It's the best-known of the disadvantages of retiring at 62, but it isn't the only one, and in 2026 it may not even be the most expensive. The other big ones: three years with no Medicare, a newly returned health insurance subsidy cliff, savings that may have to last 30 years or more, and a choice that also affects your spouse.

The good news is that you can work around most of these. The first step is to stop treating "retire at 62" as one decision. It's really several.

The disadvantages of retiring at 62, at a glance

Here's each one in more detail.

1. A Social Security check that's about 30% smaller, for life

Claim at 62 with a full retirement age of 67 and your benefit drops by up to 30%. Your next birthday doesn't bring it back. It stays reduced for the rest of your life (247 Wall St, July 2026; CPA Practice Advisor, March 2026).

The smaller check also shrinks your future raises. Cost-of-living adjustments are a percentage of your benefit, so a smaller base gets smaller raises every year after. You can see your own reduction on the SSA's early retirement calculator.

What most articles miss: retiring at 62 and claiming Social Security at 62 are two separate choices. You can stop working at 62, live on savings for a few years, and claim at 67 or 70. That spends your portfolio faster at the start. In return you get a bigger lifetime check that's adjusted for inflation. Whether that trade is worth it depends on your savings, your health, and your household.

2. Three years without Medicare, and the 2026 subsidy cliff

Medicare starts at 65. Retire at 62 and you need to cover the gap yourself, usually with an ACA marketplace plan.

This got harder in 2026. The enhanced marketplace subsidies expired at the end of 2025, which brought back the "subsidy cliff." If your income goes even $1 over 400% of the federal poverty level, you lose the premium tax credit entirely (CNBC, Jan 2026; Covered USA). Coverage of the cliff, including Fidelity's guide, puts that line at about $62,600 for a single person and $84,600 for a couple. Check the current figure for your household size before you plan around it.

Why this matters at 62: your "income" for subsidy purposes includes IRA withdrawals, capital gains, and any Social Security you claim. One large withdrawal in the wrong year can add thousands to your premiums. Boldin and Healthy FP both cover the 62-to-65 window in more depth.

The Roth conversion tradeoff

The low-income years between your last paycheck and Social Security are often described as a good window for Roth conversions, which means moving pre-tax money into a Roth account and paying the tax now at lower rates. But every dollar you convert counts as income. Convert too much and you can go over the subsidy cliff. So the tax-planning opportunity and the health insurance cost are competing for the same limited room under the line. You have to plan the two together.

3. Your savings have to last a long time

Retire at 62 and plan to 90 and you're funding 28 years. That's not unlikely. The Social Security Administration's planning guidance says about one in three 65-year-olds may live to at least 90 (SSA, Retirement Information for Medicare Beneficiaries, 2026).

A longer retirement means a lower safe withdrawal rate. Morningstar's 2025 research puts the safe starting withdrawal rate at 3.9% for a 30-year retirement. Its test: money was still there in 90% of simulated outcomes (Morningstar, The State of Retirement Income 2025, Dec 2025). At 3.9%, $800,000 supports a first-year withdrawal of about $31,200. Every year you retire early makes your savings stretch further.

That's why the plan you build with Monte Climb runs to age 95 by default, and you can extend it. Stopping at 85 quietly bets against a third of retirees.

4. Early market losses do more damage

Most "your money has to last longer" warnings skip this one. The order of your returns matters as much as the average. A market drop in the first few years of withdrawals forces you to sell investments while prices are low. That money isn't there for the recovery. The same drop ten years into retirement does much less harm.

Retiring at 62 lengthens the stretch where this can happen, and it usually means bigger early withdrawals, especially if you're delaying Social Security. Common ways to soften it: keep a cash buffer so you don't have to sell during a downturn, and be willing to cut spending in bad years.

An average-return projection can't show you this risk, because it assumes the same steady return every year. A Monte Carlo simulation runs your plan through many possible market paths, including the bad-sequence ones, and counts how often the money lasts. Monte Carlo is just that: a large set of randomized "what ifs."

5. The earnings test if you keep working

Plenty of people "retire" at 62 and then pick up part-time or consulting work. If you've already claimed Social Security, the earnings test applies. For 2026, if you're under full retirement age all year, Social Security withholds $1 for every $2 you earn above $24,480. In the year you reach full retirement age, the rule eases to $1 for every $3 above $65,160 (Nasdaq). Confirm the current limits on SSA.gov, since figures vary between sources.

A worked example: you're 63, you've claimed, and you earn $34,480. That's $10,000 over the limit, so $5,000 of benefits is withheld.

The part most articles leave out: the withheld money isn't lost for good. Once you reach full retirement age, your benefit is recalculated upward to account for it. It's a cash-flow problem more than a permanent penalty. But it can still catch you off guard.

6. Your spouse lives with your decision

If you're married, claiming early can reduce your spouse's income after you die. A widow or widower can start survivor benefits as early as 60, with a reduction for each month before full retirement age. And if the deceased worker claimed early, the survivor's benefit is lower too (Maximize My Social Security).

So the claiming decision for the higher earner should account for how long either spouse might live, not just the earner. If one of you is likely to live well into your 90s, a bigger check from waiting protects that person.

7. Health care after 65 still costs a lot

Medicare doesn't make health care free. Fidelity estimates a 65-year-old retiring in 2025 will spend $172,500 on Medicare premiums, deductibles, and prescriptions over retirement, and that figure doesn't include long-term care (Fidelity Investments, 2025 Retiree Health Care Cost Estimate, Jul 2025). Add three years of marketplace premiums before 65 and health care can become one of your largest expenses.

8. The cost that doesn't show up in the numbers

Work gives your days structure, people to talk to, and a sense of purpose. Several of the older ranking articles mention boredom after leaving work. It's real, and it's worth planning for: what will a Tuesday in March look like?

When retiring at 62 can still make sense

None of these disadvantages automatically rules out 62. Score yourself honestly:

• Health coverage: Do you have a plan for ages 62–65, and do you know where your income will land relative to the subsidy cliff?
• Bridge money: Can savings cover your spending until 67 or 70 so you can delay Social Security?
• Withdrawal rate: Is your planned spending at or below about 4% of savings, or lower if you want extra room for a long retirement?
• Spouse: Does the higher earner's claiming plan protect the survivor?
• Flexibility: Could you cut spending in a bad year, or go back to some work if you needed to?
• Starting point: Have you actually estimated your monthly spending? EBRI found only 52% of workers have (EBRI/Greenwald Retirement Confidence Survey 2025, Fact Sheet 3).

If you can answer most of these with confidence, 62 may be realistic. If several are blank, you have planning to do before you decide.

Stress-test 62 before you commit

Lists of disadvantages only go so far. What you need is the odds for your own situation. Monte Climb's retirement calculator takes three numbers: your age, your savings, and your monthly spending. It runs them through 1,000 simulated futures and tells you how many stay funded. It runs in your browser, and nothing is saved until you say so.

Then ask William, our AI planner, "Can I retire at 62?" and see how the answer changes when you test a later Social Security claim or a lower spending level. It's a probability, not a promise, and it's planning software, not advice. But it's better to break your plan on purpose now than to find out the hard way later.

Show my answer →

Frequently asked questions

How much do you lose by retiring at 62?

If you also claim Social Security at 62 and your full retirement age is 67, your monthly benefit is cut by about 30%, permanently. Future cost-of-living raises are smaller too, because they're a percentage of the reduced check.

Can I retire at 62 but wait to claim Social Security?

Yes. Retiring and claiming are separate decisions. Many people live on savings from 62 and claim at 67 or 70 to get a larger, inflation-adjusted benefit for life. The tradeoff is that you draw down your portfolio faster in the early years.

How do I get health insurance between 62 and 65?

Most early retirees use an ACA marketplace plan. In 2026 the subsidy cliff is back: if your income is even $1 over 400% of the federal poverty level, you lose the premium tax credit. That makes it important to manage IRA withdrawals, Roth conversions, and the timing of Social Security.

Can I work part-time after claiming Social Security at 62?

Yes, but the earnings test applies. In 2026, if you're under full retirement age all year, $1 of benefits is withheld for every $2 you earn above $24,480. The withheld money comes back as a higher benefit once you reach full retirement age. Confirm current limits on SSA.gov.

Does retiring at 62 affect my spouse?

It can. If the higher earner claims Social Security early, the survivor benefit the other spouse receives after that person dies is lower too. Couples should base the claiming decision on how long either spouse might live.